The Hypocrisy of Gandhi's Ahimsa: A Critical Analysis

Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi is often glorified as the embodiment of non-violence (Ahimsa), a spiritual and political giant. But peeling off the layers of hagiography reveals a different man, one who selectively applied Ahimsa, often to the detriment of Dharma, justice, and truth. His version of Ahimsa wasn't rooted in courage but in appeasement and moral posturing.

“Non-violence without justice is not Ahimsa, it is submission in disguise.” ~ Adarsh Singh

# Satya and Ahimsa: The Half-Truths That Misled a Civilization

Gandhi popularized Ahimsa and Satya, not as profound spiritual disciplines but as tools of pacification. In reality, both principles stem from Sanatan Dharma, where truth is protected through strength, and non-violence is not passive, but powerful.

The Bhagavad Gita is clear: When Dharma is under threat, even violence becomes sacred.

“Gandhi took Sanatan Dharma’s sword and replaced it with a begging bowl. That is not evolution; it is erosion.”

~ Adarsh Singh

# The Noakhali Genocide (1946): Silence When Hindus Bled

In Noakhali, Hindus faced a brutal genocide ~ rape, slaughter, forced conversions, mass terror. Gandhi’s reaction? Preach Ahimsa to the victims, not justice against the aggressors. He refused to name the perpetrators, suppressing the reality to maintain his dream of Hindu-Muslim unity.

“When you refuse to call out evil, you become a silent partner in its success.”

~ Adarsh Singh

# The Bihar Riots (1947): Outrage Only Against Hindus

When Bihar Hindus retaliated against the earlier atrocities, Gandhi threatened to fast unto death. This moral outrage was absent during the Noakhali carnage. His Ahimsa had a target - and it was always the Hindu - response, never the original aggression.

# Bhagat Singh Betrayed

While India’s youth saw Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev, and Rajguru as heroes, Gandhi refused to intercede in their execution. He opposed their methods, dismissing them as violent. But wasn’t revolution in the face of injustice also a form of resistance?

“When moral high ground is used to bury brave hearts, history bleeds in silence.”

~ Adarsh Singh

# Ahimsa Abandoned in British Wars

Gandhi’s selective Ahimsa vanished when Britain called for soldiers. He actively encouraged Indians to fight in WWI and WWII, and even volunteered in the Boer War but never supported the armed fight for India’s own freedom.

“If your sword only defends your master but never your motherland, your Ahimsa is a lie.”

~ Adarsh Singh

# The Rs. 55 Crore Gift to Pakistan

Just after the Kashmir invasion, Gandhi went on a fast to demand that India pay Rs. 55 crore to Pakistan. This was not diplomacy - it was appeasement disguised as morality.

# His Advice to Jews: Naivety as Philosophy

Gandhi advised the Jews to accept death from Hitler rather than fight back. This was not peace - it was detached idealism, disconnected from human suffering and survival.

# Selective Secularism and Anti-Hindu Bias

Gandhi included ‘Allah’ in the bhajan Raghupati Raghav Raja Ram, distorting a Hindu devotional song to promote inclusivity. He supported Namaz in temples, but never stood for Hanuman Chalisa in mosques.

“Equality is not inclusion on one side and silence on the other. That is not harmony - it’s hypocrisy.”

~ Adarsh Singh

# Crushing Hindu Identity in Congress

While the Muslim League flourished and Christian missions thrived, Gandhi ensured the Congress stayed anti-Hindu in tone. He condemned organizations that supported Hindu causes, even within constitutional and democratic frameworks.

# Swami Shraddhanand Murder: Sympathy for the Killer

In 1926, Swami Shraddhanand was assassinated by Abdul Rashid for promoting reconversion of Muslims to Hinduism. Gandhi's reaction? He called Abdul Rashid his brother, and even said he would defend him in court if asked.

This was not Ahimsa, it was a moral betrayal.

“To embrace a murderer and ignore the martyr is not tolerance, it is treachery in disguise.” ~ Adarsh Singh

# A Legacy of Confusion and Compromise

Gandhi’s version of Ahimsa was not divine, it was diplomatic, manipulative, and selectively applied. His legacy didn’t just disarm India, it disoriented its cultural compass.

“Sanatan Dharma teaches balance, when to forgive and when to fight. Gandhi broke that balance and left a nation limping in guilt.”

~ Adarsh Singh

# We Must Remember

“A half-truth repeated with devotion is more dangerous than a full lie. Gandhi’s Ahimsa was a half-truth that paralyzed an entire civilization.” ~ Adarsh Singh

Sat May 17, 2025

Say Yes to i SOUL

Adarsh Singh

Founder of iSOUL ~ Ideal School of Ultimate Life
Adarsh Singh empowers individuals to live purposefully by integrating timeless wisdom with practical tools. With 18+ years in finance and a deep connection to spirituality, his teachings blend Money, Mind, Matter(Body) and Meaning to help people create a truly fulfilling life.

The Hypocrisy of Gandhi's Ahimsa: A Critical Analysis

# Satya and Ahimsa: The Half-Truths That Misled a Civilization

# The Noakhali Genocide (1946): Silence When Hindus Bled

# The Bihar Riots (1947): Outrage Only Against Hindus

# Bhagat Singh Betrayed

# Ahimsa Abandoned in British Wars

# The Rs. 55 Crore Gift to Pakistan

# His Advice to Jews: Naivety as Philosophy

# Selective Secularism and Anti-Hindu Bias

# Crushing Hindu Identity in Congress

# Swami Shraddhanand Murder: Sympathy for the Killer

# A Legacy of Confusion and Compromise

# We Must Remember

Say Yes to iSOUL

You may also be interested in

Say Yes to i SOUL